Heading into Week 12 of the 2025 MLB season, a selection of injured players awaits opportunity for fantasy baseball managers. These top 25 stash-worthy players are currently rostered in under 65% of leagues, making them ideal candidates for injury replacement in lineups.

Among the notable names are Bryce Miller of the Seattle Mariners, who is recovering from elbow issues with a projected return in late July, and Lance McCullers Jr. from the Houston Astros, expected back in early July after dealing with a foot injury. Both players possess high upside potential upon their return, making them must-stash options.

Wilyer Abreu of the Boston Red Sox, despite being sidelined with an oblique injury, remains a valuable asset due to the recent trade of Rafael Devers, ensuring him a spot in the lineup once activated. Other players like Grayson Rodriguez and Noelvi Marte present exciting late-season potential. Managers should monitor these injuries closely and consider roster adjustments to capitalize on the returning talent.

The Cincinnati Reds are facing injury challenges while trying to maintain momentum in the MLB. Jake Fraley remains on the injured list, but his absence is mitigated by Will Benson's outstanding performance, earning him the National League Player of the Week honors. Benson hit .526 with five home runs and led the majors in multiple offensive categories. Meanwhile, the team is managing other injuries, including Noelvi Marte and Christian Encarnacion-Strand, with tentative timelines for their returns. Terry Francona provided updates on their status, indicating that some players are showing positive signs in their recovery.

The Cincinnati Reds have called up outfielder Rece Hinds from Triple-A Louisville, filling the gap left by Noelvi Marte, who has been placed on the injured list due to an oblique strain. Hinds showcased his power at Louisville, hitting a home run in three consecutive games and boasting a .281 batting average with eight homers over 138 plate appearances this season. The 24-year-old made a notable debut last July, becoming the first player since Willie Mays to achieve multiple hitting milestones in a five-day span.

Hinds has become known for his explosive starts, including a home run in his first at-bat of the 2024 spring training against the Milwaukee Brewers. His previous MLB debut was memorable, marked by a spectacular sliding catch and a 449-foot homer. As a second-round draft pick in 2019, Hinds opted for a professional career over college baseball at LSU after high school. Despite battling injuries in earlier seasons, his potential as a power hitter is now on display as he steps into a major league role.

The Cincinnati Reds continue to struggle with injuries as Noelvi Marte has been placed on the 10-day injured list due to side pain. This adds to the growing list of Reds players currently sidelined, including Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Jeimer Candelario, and Austin Hays. Marte's recent slump saw his batting average drop to .294, despite a strong start to the season. Rece Hinds has been recalled from Triple-A Louisville to fill Marte's spot. Hinds had previously made a notable debut but faced challenges afterwards, with a recent streak of 0-for-16. On a positive note, Rhett Lowder has begun his rehab assignment with the Rookie-ACL Reds after dealing with a forearm strain.

As Week 6 of the 2025 fantasy baseball season approaches, savvy managers are seeking opportunities to enhance their rosters through strategic trades. Identifying undervalued players to buy low can turn the tide for teams struggling in the standings, while moving on from overvalued players can prevent future disappointments.

Dylan Cease of the San Diego Padres is highlighted as a prime candidate to target. Despite a rough start and a 5.76 ERA, Cease's history of consistency and upcoming favorable matchups against teams like the Pittsburgh Pirates, Los Angeles Angels, and Toronto Blue Jays suggest a potential rebound is on the horizon. Meanwhile, Cincinnati Reds' Matt McLain is another buy-low option. His slow start is understandable given his previous injuries, and his peripherals indicate he possesses the talent to improve as the season progresses.

On the flip side, players like Noelvi Marte and Andy Pages are flagged as overvalued assets. Marte's impressive early numbers may be misleading due to poor underlying metrics, while Pages' recent hot streak may not be sustainable. Fantasy managers should consider trading these players before their values decrease. In contrast, acquiring players like Cease and McLain could provide substantial returns as the season progresses.